BradReese.Com Cisco Hardware Quotes Call Toll Free 877-549-2680 or 828-277-7272

Home About Repair Power Supplies Refurbished Blog Quick Links Site Map Contact Us

 
Brad Reese speaks out
Learn more about Brad Reese...
Archive
  Help

Aironet

Power Supplies

VoIP Gateways

Cisco Repair

Refurbished Cisco

Cisco CPQRGs

New Cisco

New HP ProCurve

Cisco Tools

Competitive Lab Tests

Tech Forums

How-to Tutorials

CCIE Gossip

Blogroll

 
View archive of Brad Reese speaks out

Subscribe

Cisco's Nexus 9000 honcho slams famous CCIE Emeritus over Application Centric Infrastructure (ACI)

"For the amount of time Cisco has invested in you to help you understand what ACI is and isn't, you forever get it wrong... Final comments - I realize after writing this that I am the fool for validating this comic book of pseudo-networking BS."

Hummelstown, PA:   Mon, 5/26/14 - 11:59pm    View comments
 

Update 7/29/14 - 2:19pm:

"Software licensing, hardware costs, and bundles for starters and Catalyst 6500 upgrades."

Network World: A breakdown of Cisco ACI pricing
 

Update 6/1/2014 - 4:55pm:

$125K entry level street price for Cisco application centric infrastructure (ACI)
 



 

CCIE Emeritus Greg Ferro and Cisco CEO John Chambers

 

CiscoFrank D'AgostinoAccording to Cisco's Nexus 9000 honcho, Frank D'Agostino, Cisco has "invested" a lot of time to educate CCIE Emeritus Greg Ferro on the merits of Cisco's Application Centric Infrastructure (ACI).

Thus D'Agostino was none too pleased with Ferro's most recent perspective on Cisco's ACI:

Cisco Faces Make-Or-Break Week For SDN

"The big question around ACI is that of customer acceptance. Customers that are holding back on Cisco are reluctant to speak publicly, but internal sources talk about significant pushback against ACI on the basis of proprietary technology, complexity, and high pricing.

"Many organizations perceive that deploying ACI will create a dependency on Cisco technology, not just for routing and switching, but also for UCS servers, firewalls and IDS, and Invicta storage."

Frank D'Agostino is the Senior Director responsible for the product development and technical go to market for Cisco's Nexus 9000, Application Centric Infrastructure (ACI) and the Application Virtual Switch.

So when Greg Ferro published his most recent ACI perspective, D'Agostino let loose the following diatribe:
 

  • Greg,

    For the amount of time Cisco has invested in you to help you understand what ACI is and isn't, you forever get it wrong. Cisco is not catching up to anyone with ACI, nor SDN for that matter. You financial information is wrong, your technical information is wrong, and your marketing info is what, wrong.

    I genuinely enjoy talking to you and like our exchanges, but I know the outcome is always a negative slant to get headlines.

    My recommendation is to go get a balanced view, by someone who also has a reputation of being tough on Cisco, Jim Duffy at Network World, who posted a very balanced view in the article below.

    http://www.networkworld.com/community/node/85455

    If you want more BS info such as this, try the following link:

    http://www.nationalenquirer.com

  • Being technical is no excuse for puposefully misinforming people. You want to be tough, be tough that is fair. I also know the difference between technical people and journalist having built data centers and networks for more than 25 years and with a CCIE and various other certs.

    Greg and I have had direct exchanges on this and BS is BS. Journalist or rocket scientist, it all smells the same.

  • Final comments - I realize after writing this that I am the fool for validating this comic book of pseudo-networking BS.
  • BS#1 - ACI is catching up to competing strategies from than VMware NSX and HP VAN.

    Response - ACI is providiing far more than NSX will ever be able to do and a 7 year old company that cannot show 20 customers with full features at scale, they are incomplete also as you have to plug it into something and buy hw gateways for vxlan and cannot do network virtualization for any platform, nor can they even do it for VSS, VDS, or any other edge other than the NSX vswitch. Greg knows better

  • BS#2 - Customers that are holding back on Cisco are reluctant to speak publicly, but internal sources talk about significant pushback against ACI on the basis of proprietary technology, complexity, and high pricing.

    Response - This is pure BS, Greg has no idea on pricing, how open the platform is and the fact that we can not only existing on existing infrastructure but ACI can be extended over competitive infrastructure. Greg do your homework...

  • BS#3 - Many organizations perceive that deploying ACI will create a dependency on Cisco technology, not just for routing and switching, but also for UCS servers, firewalls and IDS, and Invicta storage.

    Response - Customers can run python scripting, puppet, chef, openflow, and ACI, with NXOS mode or ACI mode. There is no dependency as Greg states - just another shovel full.

  • BS#4 - Some critics make the point that Cisco has been promoting ACI to customers since mid—2013. Cisco has 75% market share, which makes these numbers seem low compared to the total number of addressable customers.

    Response - This is a clear indication to me that the author knows nothing about taking a product to market. Maybe we should be a 7 year old, agile software company, who cannot produce 20 referenceable customers at full features and scale. Amazingly poor understanding of a market.

  • BS#5 - On the other hand, slow uptake is to be expected because ACI is an early-stage technology, highly disruptive to IT operations, and the product is not yet shipping.

    Response - Complete mis-information. Greg has no idea what customers we have in production, it is not highly disruptive - maybe I should put a SDN LAN emulation model in place that forces me to have a bunch of x86 appliances recreating ATM LAN Emulation on x86, terrible traffic flows, having to build a separate network for management, vmotion - live migration, controllers, and have low scale, force a bunch of NAT domains, and oh, by the way, force to rip out ever vswitch, upgrade every vswitch from the new system to fix lousy performance of OVS, and not be able to accomodate any other platform because VMware is locking everyone out of the kernel.

  • BS#6 - The early-adopter model is well entrenched at Cisco to seed deployments for companies willing to take risks so that deployments are ready at launch. Cisco executives will, of course, assure you that they are pleased with the uptake and customer interest to date. The early marketing program has been as vigorous and comprehensive as Cisco can make it, and many customers are looking forward to ACI.

    Response - Not sure what to say here other than your writer needs to put on an orange wig, red nose, and floppy shoes.

  • BS#7 - One final concern is purchase price. VMware NSX pricing has been widely criticized in recent months. This is in part because of its emphasis on rental licensing, but mostly because it is simply expensive and perceived as overpriced. Cisco is already known for high product pricing, but until actual ACI/APIC pricing is available, a proper evaluation cannot be made. Customers are looking to reduce their overall IT spend, and any attempt to increase top-line spending is likely to meet significant resistance.

    Response - Do your homework Greg, others have and you clearly have not.

  • BS#8 - Cisco has had a few quarters of poor business with mixed outcomes in different business units. In the last two quarters alone, profits and revenue have dropped by 5% or more, with the gross profit margin now reduced to slightly more than 60%. Most financial news suggests that Cisco's share price has remained flat due to huge buybacks of shares. Cisco has announced a $10 billion share buyback, funded by debt raising in the US and backed by $30 billion net cash in offshore funds.

    Response - Not only do you mis-reprsent technical data, you have no clear idea on how to do financial analyst.

  • It is easier to hide behind.... "the customer said" any bad journalist can say that. Good journalists have validation - not conjecture that can be present on any slide or bad blog message.

    Customers know best how to take a product to market - they have to install it... If customers are your source, and an engineer is writing the blog who is not an expert at go to market - then how credible is your opinion. In my view 0. Leveraging a big name like network computing as a platform makes it all the more important to be credible. In other words, if you don't know - don't FUD.

    This is my last blog post here and my recommendation moving forward to customers, resources, and internal, is to drop this platform to a lower tier from credibility to variable rhetoric.

    The last thing I am going to do is send customers here. Good luck.

  • Yes, check my profile on LinkedIn. I am Frank D'Agostino, Senior Director at Cisco Systems who is responsible for product development and technical go to market for Application Centric Infrastructure (ACI), the Nexus 9000, and the Application Virtual Switch.

    I was also formerly the VP of WW Technical Operations at Nicira Networks and left prior to the acquisition of Nicira by VMware because I knew ACI was going to go far beyond where SDN LAN Emulation - this decade's version of ATM LAN Emulation on x86, was going to end up.

    Not trying to hide my profile, just try to spend as little time on worthless blogs as possible, except when the company makes significant investments trying to educate someone who puposefully twists information and misinforms the public community.

    I realized I also lied, I said I wouldn't be back on this website.


 

View the Worldwide Cisco CCIE Count.

More CCIE Water Cooler Gossip.

Related documents:

Cisco's Application Centric Infrastructure (ACI)

HP VAN SDN Controller

VMware NSX

Related stories:

Network World: A breakdown of Cisco ACI pricing

Cisco Nexus 9000 switch starts at $79K for 288 ports

$125K entry level street price for Cisco application centric infrastructure (ACI)

Network World: TCO of Cisco ACI 3X better than VMware NSX

Network Computing: Cisco Faces Make-Or-Break Week For SDN
 


What's your take?

Contact Brad Reese

Brad's Favorite Story Picks

  1. Cisco buys Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) funded ThreatGRID
  2. John Chambers dumped 26% (750,000 shares) of his Cisco stake while giving Cisco Live keynote speech May 19, 2014
  3. Dave Evans Cisco's Internet of Everything (IoE) futurist/evangelist has hightailed it to stealth start-up
  4. Cisco CEO John Chambers sends letter to President Barack Obama seeking NSA reform
  5. Is it illegal to buy or sell gray market Cisco hardware with embedded software?
  6. Rumor Cisco channel VP Maria Cannon is out
  7. Cisco's 9-month FY14 revenue plunged only -$1.4 billion year-over-year
  8. Concerned that full-time Cisco CCIE proctors are not CCIE certified
  9. Top secret document contradicts Cisco's denial of NSA spy cooperation
  10. Did Cisco's videoscape czar Jesper Andersen get the guillotine?
  11. Rumor Cisco's $14 trillion Internet of Things (IoT) general manager, Guido Jouret, has resigned
  12. Cisco Systems: The greatest stock-laundering machine ever invented
  13. Cisco CCIE salaries in India have plunged -50%
  14. Vexed Cisco CEO John Chambers vows to outsell tiny Arista Networks
  15. HP OpenNFV vs. Cisco ACI
  16. Prediction: Soni Jiandani will be appointed Cisco CEO in May 2014
  17. Critique on Cisco channel partner program by former Cisco sales executive, Kevin Avery
  18. IPO comparison: Arista Networks vs. Box, Inc.
  19. Why Cisco passed on buying VMware
  20. View the archive of Bloggers speak out on BradReese.Com
 
Subscribe
comments powered by Disqus

Supplement Cisco SMARTnet Contracts

 

©2014 Alliance Networking LLC - Home - About - Repair - Power Supplies - Refurbished - Blog - Quick Links - Site Map - Contact Us